Freeing Employer Speech - California's Spending Restrictions Violate Employers' Rights to Oppose Unions
Oceanside, CA (PRWEB) July 1, 2008 -- Employer defense attorney, Clifton Smith, SPHR, comments on the recent, US Supreme Court ruling declaring that California Assembly Bill 1889, which regulated employer free speech by imposing spending restrictions on the use of state funds, violates and is preempted by the National Labor Relations Act.
Vindicating the free speech rights of California employers, the United States Supreme Court, in a 7-2 decision, has overturned California laws that unlawfully interfered with every employer's constitutionally protected right to engage in free debate about the question of union representation under the National Labor Relations Act. The Court reached its decision in the case of The Chamber of Commerce of the United States of America, et.al., v. Brown (Opinion No. 06-939, June 19, 2008).
The US Chamber of Commerce and others challenged enforcement of California Assembly Bill 1889 (AB 1889). This law prevented private employers that received more than $10,000.00 in state funds in any year (Cal. Gov't. Code § 16645.7) from using state funds to "assist, promote or deter union organizing (Cal. Gov't Code §§ 16645-16647(b)(d)).
Mr. Smith observed that "the State of California claimed that its prohibition against the use of state funds to oppose unions promoted its policy of neutrality on the question of unionization. However, AB 1889 was clearly another example of state sponsored, pro-union, anti-employer legislation." AB 1889 specifically allowed expenditure of state funds for certain activities that promoted unionization, such as the use of state funds to provide the union access to the employer's property, or the use of state funds for activities in any way associated with the employer's voluntary recognition of the union. (Cal. Gov't Code § 16647(b)(d)).
Attorney Smith stated that, "with AB 1889, California created a comprehensive enforcement scheme designed to intimidate California employers and extinguish their right to free speech." Its broad prohibition against the use of state funds to oppose unionization included expenditures for legal fees, consulting fees, and even the payment of salaries of supervisors or other employees whom an employer might utilize to oppose a union.
Employers were required to maintain records and also certify that state funds had not been used to oppose unionization. A false certification would expose the offending employer to criminal prosecution. If an employer commingled state funds in any way with other funds used to deter union organizing, AB 1889 created a conclusive presumption that the employer had used state funds for an unlawful purpose. Violators were subject to civil penalties amounting to treble damages, plus attorneys fees and costs. "This law was another invitation to sue employers who opposed the union," concluded Mr. Smith. "The enforcement action could be brought by either the state attorney general or any private taxpayer, including a union engaged in a labor dispute with an employer receiving state funds."
The U.S. Supreme Court emphasized that the National Labor Relations Act favored an uninhibited, robust and wide-open debate in labor disputes. It stressed that the freewheeling use of the written and spoken word had been expressly fostered by Congress and approved by the National Labor Relations Board. The Court reversed the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals judgment and remanded the case for further proceedings consistent with its opinion.
"This ruling upholds a California employer's right to speak out in opposition to the union, even if the employer spends state funds to do so," states Attorney Smith. The Court's ruling appears to pave the way for California employers who receive state funds, such as hospitals or other state licensed facilities, to use such funds to oppose unionization of their employees by all legal means, without violating California state law. It appears that the state's record-keeping and certification requirements required by AB 1889 are also voided by the US Supreme Court's ruling. As Mr. Smith concluded, "California employers that receive state funds will no longer face the specter of state civil or criminal prosecution for exercising their constitutionally protected right to engage in a partisan debate about unionization."
###
Related Articles:
Sea Trail Golf Resort & Convention Center Hosts Inaugural Golf Writers Invitational Tournament
Writers From Throughout The Eastern United States And Canada Competed To Win The "Sea Trail Golf Writers Invitational"
Travel, Golf & Entertainment News Available To Writers Through Online Press Room
Myrtle Beach-Based LHWH'S Virtual News Room Is Updated Daily To Provide Media With Most Current Information
Southern California Hospital Makes Women's Sexual Health a Priority, Naming World-Renown Expert in Sexual Health and Survivorship Medicine as New Pro
Hoag Hospital named Dr. Michael Krychman, one of the world's leading experts in sexual health and survivorship medicine, the medical director of its new Sexual Health and Survivorship Medicine program.
Florida Health Insurance Highlights 2008 Presidential Health Care Plans
FloridaHealthInsuranceWeb.com, a health insurance consultant service, has published a non-partisan report of each of presidential candidates positions on healthcare. 'The upcoming elections will impact Florida's health care system' said consultant Morgan Moran in a phone interview, 'it's up to you as Florida residents to turn out January 29 and choose which candidate delivers the best insurance plan'.
Patti Kouri's Formula of Extraordinary People Jumpstarts Real Estate in 2008
Coach Patti Kouri of Accelerated Performance Coaching, conducted a workshop in November of 2007. The participants of the workshop began an unprecedented experiment. Their goal was to create a book using the participation of leading real estate agents to prepare them for the 2008 market. Real Estate in 2008 -- Top Agents Share Top Ideas is now a reality.
Real Estate Price Gains Attract New Buyers To Malta
British and European investors looking for high growth in 2007 are hoping for a repeat of the property inflation seen in Malta when it joined the EU in 2004, and it could become reality with the news that low cost airlines are to fly to the island, giving their real estate industry expectation that 2007 could be an exceptional year for price rises and sales.
Propertyshark.Com Collaborates with Corcoran To Release Manhattan Real Estate Report: Second Quarter Of 2008 Sees A 38% Decline In Residential Transac
PropertyShark.com, in collaboration with the Corcoran Group, today announce the release of the first Corcoran Report with sales data audited and supplemented by PropertyShark.com. The Corcoran Report covers Manhattan residential real estate sales for the second quarter of 2008. Key Takeaways from 2Q08 Manhattan Sales include new information on sales transactions, median sale prices and on the region of Manhattan.
Home Equity Loan California
Having your own home is not some easy these days, and in certain location some people find it hard to deal with all the financial issues. Many find that their dreams of owning a piece of land are hindered by the increasing price of real estate and the decreasing value of money. This is especially true in places like California where everyone seems to be set on living. If you are looking for information about California home loans, then the internet is the best place to go.
Price Cutters Expanding in Florida with Two New Stores
Price Cutter opens Price Cutter Pantry in North Ft. Myers and Arcadia.
Earth Buses Launches a Fleet of Eco-Friendly Luxury Limousine Buses - First of its Kind in Las Vegas
Earth Buses launches a fleet of eco-friendly luxury limousine buses - first of its kind in Las Vegas. Earth Buses is Las Vegas' first and only environmentally friendly luxury limo bus service run entirely on renewable fuel sources.